Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: The Most Dangerous Division in Sports

New CBA Draft Changes May Affect the Nationals


If you haven't heard, MLB came to an agreement with the player's union that lasts until 2023. In that deal their was some changes to the draft, here is a detailed explanation:

For years, people in baseball—including Baseball America—had called for various ideas to tweak the draft. Such talks usually increased as the renewal of a labor deal approached, but other issues inevitably took center stage and the draft was left for later. This time around, commissioner Bud Selig made draft changes an emphasis in Major League Baseball's negotiating position, and the sport's peace in larger issues left time to tackle the issue.

In addition to the signing bonus pool, the new CBA also changes free agent compensation and seeks to award more picks to low-revenue teams.

Starting in 2012, the familiar Type A and Type B free agents, based on the Elias ranking system, will be eliminated. Now the only free agents subject to compensation will be those who are offered contracts equal to the average salary of the 125 highest-paid players in the game as they enter the free-agent process. Players also have to be with a team for an entire season to be subject to compensation, so pending free agents who are traded at midseason will not generate extra picks for the teams that acquire them.

A team that signs one of those free agents will give up its first-round pick. Unlike before, when the top 15 overall picks were protected, now only the top 10 are protected. In those cases, the team will lose its second-highest selection (not necessarily its second-round pick, as before).

There's also a lottery for six extra picks following both the first and second rounds. Teams that are in the bottom 10 in revenue and/or market size go into a pool for six picks after the first round, with odds of winning based on the prior season's winning percentage. Teams that don't get one of those picks—and any other team that receives money from revenue sharing—then goes into another lottery for six picks after the second round. The odds of winning are based on prior season winning percentage.

A couple of other notable draft changes:

• The draft will continue to be conducted in June, but the signing deadline will be moved to a date between July 12-18, depending on the date of the All-Star Game. Since 2007, the deadline has been in mid-August.

"I think that's a win-win for everyone," Savage said. "The guys that want to go out will go out. They'll be able to get out in their short seasons and play right away. I think Major League Baseball will like that. It's also a win on the college side; it gives you a little time to recover (from unexpected draft losses). It at least gives you 60 days, in some cases 90 days, to re-evaluate where you're at, roster-wise, and if you do have money available you can go out and get somebody at that time."
 
• No more major league deals, as drafted players may only sign minor league contracts. 

• Free-agent compensation picks awarded by lottery "may be assigned" by a club, which would seem to indicate they can be traded. If correct, that would be a draft first.
 
• The top 200 prospects will be subject to a predraft drug test and will participate in a predraft medical program as well. 

International Changes Coming

The changes to the amateur scene also affect things internationally, with a cap for the 2012-2013 signing period. Jeff Passan of Yahoo! Sports reported that the cap will be $2.9 million for all teams in the first year, and it will be adjusted for subsequent years based on winning percentage.

The penalties are as noted above, and the agreement says the penalties will increase in 2014-15 "if a draft or drafts is not agreed to by July 2014." Several sources said an international draft is a clear goal in the next few years.

Starting with the 2013-14 signing period (July 2, 2013-June 15, 2014), teams will be allowed to trade a portion of their international cap space, subject to certain (though unspecified) restrictions.

Star-divide

Basically what this means is this: 

 

Teams like the Nationals, Pirates, Astros, etc. have been spending over 15 million dollars in the draft to get fresh talent, in fact last year we spent 17 million dollars, but with the new draft changes, we can now only spend 10 million at the most. This is a major problem, because now it will be very hard to make deals with top prospects who want far more than just 10 million. It will also be hard to intice multi-sport players with a lot of money. I hope they can revise these changes, they will have many unforseen consequences.

Poll
Do you want MLB and the CBA to revise these changes?
Yes Please!
11 votes
Meh
5 votes

16 votes | Poll has closed

Comment 5 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

The changes aren't that bad.

We’ve had basically three once-in-a-lifetime type drafts in a row – two with hands down #1 picks, and one with basically four premium 1st-rounders – and I don’t think Rizzo was counting on getting away with it forever. He’s done what Bowden should have done years ago, which is aggressively go after the best prospects available with every pick. Now that the farm system is relatively well-stocked at every level, and we have bonafide Major Leaguers on our ML roster, we don’t need a big draft bonanza. We have prospects to trade for veterans if we need ML help, and we have veterans to trade for prospects if we don’t.

As for signability issues, I’m not the least bit concerned.

If a player won’t sign because he’s not getting offered over slot, then by all means let him go unsigned. Only a handful of guys can get drafted in the top ten, and it’s now gotten significantly harder for most draftees to cash in. If they want to risk getting taken at the same slot or lower next year, then f*** ‘em – they’re too stupid for our team anyway. Otherwise fair is fair.

If a player won’t sign because he can make more money out of the gate by signing in the NFL, then again, by all means let him go. If he’d rather be facing the near-certitude of permanent injury on the gridiron, and ultimately shorten his playing career (and earning potential) by a minimum of five years just to make an extra million up front, then he’s so stupid I wouldn’t want him on my team.

The upside to this is that the drama of “will they or won’t they” that we’ve had to endure for the last four years won’t happen again. We can draft guys, and they can just sign right away and start playing. It really is win-win.

by rarumberger on Nov 24, 2011 5:57 PM EST reply actions  

This is really bad for small market teams

It is no accident that teams like the Nats and the Bucs have easily outpaced the league in over-slotting… it is simply one of the few ways that smaller market/less desireable to free agent teams can have a hope of competing against the big guys. While the Yanks and Phils get whomever they want in FA, they aren’t so concerned overpaying for prospects. But others, who can’t hope to compete with FAs, have few other opportunities, and now one of the best has been taken away.

The best reason I can come up with for why MLB went for even less, not more, competitive balance is because they want to better reflect a country that is, every year, becoming better for the rich and worse for the poor…

by William.Hatheway on Nov 30, 2011 11:15 AM EST reply actions  

Of course,

the Nats aren’t really a small-market team. They’ve just played like a small-market team in years past. Now they’ve been cajoled into ‘spending to their potential’.

Rob

-- In baseball we trust.

by RobBobS on Nov 30, 2011 11:57 AM EST up reply actions  

OTOH

Prospects with school options can no longer take a hard line position on signing bonuses. In the past a player could essentially tell teams that don’t go over slot not to bother drafting them unless they brought their cash – so they would tend to slip past those teams to later spots where teams like the Yankees or Nationals could pick them off.

It will be interesting to see how this plays out. More players will go to/return to college, yes; but there also may be a wider dispersal of prospects to all teams rather than all of the top prospects ending up with the teams willing to go well over slot.

by d_c_guy on Nov 30, 2011 12:11 PM EST up reply actions  

OTOOH

Some player could tell certain teams not to bother drafting them. Think of Harper announcing that if anyone besides NYY drafts him in 2010, then he will go back to college another year. Then (1) some other team could waste a top pick just to keep Harper off the Yankees (unlikely), or (2) the Yankees pick him 32th in the draft, for a huge bargain because it was so far down the line. Now, maybe YOU wouldn’t be offended by that turn of events, but I sure would be!

Rob

-- In baseball we trust.

by RobBobS on Nov 30, 2011 2:49 PM EST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation's blog about the Washington Nationals. Federalbaseball.com Trying To Make Every Fan A Nationals' Fan.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Cat_coons_small
***Pick6!!!>>>'''PLAY NOW'''<<<Pick6!!!***
Bugs-bunny-baseball_small
New GuessEm Rankings (5/24)

Recent FanPosts

45859-188-008f_small
Why don't more players -- and teams -- do vision training?
Marion2_small
Odd Baseball Question
Joker460_1__small
Philly-Tears Milkshake Brings This Boy Back to The Yahd!
Small
No excuses... too many men left on base
Small
Speed Camera on I-395 in DC coming from VA
Small
Harper HR Poll
Photo-1_small
A few takes, and some queries, from a neophyte
Small
The Gathering Storm

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

GAMETHREAD SPONSOR

Masn_medium

Yahoo_full_count

Ministry of Peace

Rizzo__kasten_and_chigliak_small Patrick Reddington

Ministry of Truth: Records Department (Editor)

Ws1_small Winston Smith

Ministry of Plenty

Teddy_clip_small Doghouse

Shadedlogo_small Dave at District Sports Page

Youppi_040618_mon_a_small bluelineswinger

Small d_c_guy

Adam_o_small jeff550

Imag0320_small SaratogaCountySports