Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Devils Beat Rangers, Head To Stanley Cup Finals

Worst "Quality Start" Ever


After John Lannan produced the following line last night:

5 2/3 IP, 11 H, 3 R, 3 ER, 2 BB, 2 SO

I called it "one out away from the worst quality start ever." The quality start statistic has also popped up occasionally on MASN broadcasts, usually to criticism from F.P. Santangelo. By the way, F.P., if you ever need examples to discredit the quality start, check out some of the ones highlighted below.

Anyway, it was the Lannan start that made me curious--what really is the worst quality start ever? After all, Lannan allowed no unearned runs, no home runs, and his Game Score was 35. Not good, but surely there's been worse, yes? Indeed.

To the Baseball Reference Play Index!

I decided that the "worst" quality start would be the shortest possible (6 IP) with the fewest earned runs allowed possible (3).

This basic start gives us 8,388 games since 1919. I decided to proceed by ranking the search by hits, in descending order. The most hits in a quality start (retroactive to 1919, of course) is 15. You might recognize the pitcher's name, and also find the opponent most curious:

http://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/WS2/WS2196607020.shtml

Ford allowed 10 runs (!), but only 3 were earned, on 15 hits, 4 of which were home runs.

I was fairly sure I had already found the start I was looking for, but I kept going a little bit. After all, perhaps someone allowed more than 7 unearned runs in one of these starts. And, lo, it is so: the record here is 9, for 12 total runs.

http://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/BOS/BOS192409300.shtml

Yet again, we have the Senators--of course, these are the original Senators, who eventually became the Twins, not those knockoffs that later skedaddled to Texas. But that's beside the point. I still think Ford's start is worse, mostly on account of the homers, despite the different eras these games were played in.

Going back to that Ford start, has anyone else pulled off the seemingly daunting task of allowing more home runs (4) than earned runs (3), in a so-called "quality start" no less? As it turns out, no. Ford is the only pitcher to do this.

But I was not yet quite ready to give up. Ford may have allowed 15 hits, but he walked nobody. What's the record here, for most walks in a quality start? Ten.

Yes, ten. Behold:

http://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/DET/DET195506080.shtml

Most curious, another Yankee. Of course, you can pretty quickly tell that the walks are the only extraordinary thing here: 5 strikeouts somewhat mitigate things, and he allowed just 5 hits and no unearned runs. This is hardly horrific.

Of course, only after all this effort did I think of the Game Score statistic. However, Game Score also produced the Ford and Speece starts, with their ugly scores of 16. But then I removed the innings cap, and found a Game Score of 14.

http://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/BRO/BRO192209202.shtml

That start almost defies words. And not just because we will never again see 20-hit complete games.

I could go on to different metrics, but I think I found my answer with that initial search. Hall of Famer Whitey Ford is the only pitcher to allow 15 hits or 4 home runs in a quality start, let alone both. I hereby declare him the producer of the Worst Quality Start (Retroactively) of All Time.

Of course, I keep adding that word "retroactively." The quality start was not invented until 1985. I just went ahead and looked for the lowest Game Score this time, and found a 26. Although no Whitey Ford, this pitcher was pretty good in his own right:

Lowest Game Score (26): http://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/TEX/TEX200007050.shtml

Another post-85 start worth mentioning is the following. You may recognize a key figure on this game's winning team:

http://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/SDN/SDN199404080.shtml

Baseball Reference doesn't recognize the FIP statistic, but this start produced roughly a 11.1 FIP, which I imagine is the worst ever for an alleged quality start.

Anyway, 700 words on this is more than enough. Suffice it to say I overreacted in labeling the Lannan start last night as almost the worst ever quality start, as tough as that performance was to watch.

Let me know which of the starts listed here impresses you most in its awfulness, or tell me about any other games I might have missed.

UPDATE 6/29

Looking back on it, I decided that one thing missing from my post yesterday was a sufficient connection to the Nationals beyond Lannan's start on Monday. So now I will look into the worst quality starts in Nationals history (not Expos; 2005-present). This time, I didn't search for anything except the lowest Game Scores with IP>=6 and ER<=3. 

Lannan's start from Monday came a lot closer to being the worst quality start in Nationals history, rather than the worst one ever. In fact, it was basically there.

We will assume that Lannan would have gotten the 18th out without further damage. This would actually add 3 points to his game score (1 for the 18th out and 2 for completing the 6th inning), producing in the end a game score of 38. Only one pitcher in Nationals history has achieved a quality start with a game score that low.

Care to guess? No?

It's John Lannan:   http://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/WAS/WAS200905040.shtml 

At least he got a W that time. 

By the way, there have apparently been 457 quality starts in Nationals history. We have played 1,051 games. I am now wondering where that 43.5% mark ranks among all teams since 2005. I imagine pretty low, but I'll leave that research to somebody else.

Comment 11 comments  |  3 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Lannan is better than Whitey Ford!!!

"Another K for Werth. Tosses the bat and the helmet. Staggering." - A. Kilgore

by cat daddy3000 on Jun 28, 2011 8:11 PM EDT reply actions  

How about worst shutouts?

Your post brought to mind a game in which the original Senators nemesis Jim "Mudcat’ Grant pitched a 14-hit shutout for the Indians. The Senators had such a bad record against him that before one game fans and broadcasters used voodoo dolls to “break the jinx/spell” he had over them. Does anyone else remember Mudcat.

by wreckhouse on Jun 28, 2011 8:40 PM EDT reply actions  

Remember Mudcat? How the hell could I forget him?

Jim “Mudcat” Grant owned the Washington Senators. They even held a “Beat Mudcat” day at Griffith Stadium, with big “Beat Mudcat” buttons the give-away. Before the game, Grant cheerfully put on a button and posed for the Washington Post photographer – then he went out and beat us yet again.

After the Senators moved to Minnesota and became the Twinkies, they traded for Mudcat. He won 20 for them in ’65, and they won the pennant.

"The key to winning baseball games is pitching, fundamentals, and three run homers." - Earl Weaver

by Whupass on Jun 29, 2011 10:40 AM EDT up reply actions  

Another way to look at these things is by the number of baserunners allowed

The most astounding game I found was from Bob Smith. He allowed 29 runners in a game considered to be a quality start. That does sound incredible, but it’s made even more amazing when you see he pitched a 22-inning complete game! He faced 89 batters! So, this may not represent pure badness, but it sure must have been a painful game to watch.

You might want to check out the pitcher Burleigh Grimes. He had not one or two but SEVERAL “questionable” quality starts, including one 9-inning quality start in which he allowed 23 base runners. I’ll say that again: 23 base runners. That’s a WHIP of over 2.5 for a game — most pitchers nowadays would not make it out of the third with those kinds of numbers, regardless of the numbers of runs scored. This particular start gets my nomination. http://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/BRO/BRO192409070.shtml

Rob

-- In baseball we trust.

by RobBobS on Jun 29, 2011 12:14 PM EDT reply actions  

Yeah, it was a different game back then

Let’s not forget that when pro ball first started back in the late 19th century batters were allowed to request either a high or low pitch. I imagine Michael Morse would have an OPS of about 2.000 in that kind of league…

by Tony Farrar on Jun 29, 2011 1:39 PM EDT up reply actions  

Foul balls weren't even counted as strikes until around 1890.

(Pro ball actually started right after the Civil War)

"The key to winning baseball games is pitching, fundamentals, and three run homers." - Earl Weaver

by Whupass on Jun 29, 2011 2:18 PM EDT up reply actions  

And balls bouncing over the fence were HRs

not to mention a few adjustments to pitching distance/allowable style, fences/lack thereof, equipment, etc. etc. etc.

Brain: "Pinky, are you pondering what i'm pondering?"
Pinky: "Yes, but isn't a cucumber that small called a gherkin?"

by jbg2772 on Jun 29, 2011 4:16 PM EDT up reply actions  

Tony or Whup or anyone else, ever read “Game of Inches” by Peter Morris? It’s basically an encyclopedia of the development of baseball, mostly in the 19th century since that’s when so much of it occurred.

Rob (or do you prefer Bob, lol), interesting about Grimes. I guess when the spitter was going places he didn’t expect he had issues, and I guess that happened a lot. Although, 23 baserunners in 9 innings is only slightly higher than the 15 in 6 allowed by Ford, and I still can’t get over allowing more homers than earned runs, even though that’s obviously easily doable based on the “should be 3 outs” rule.

As for Bob Smith, I think the ultimate fan would be one on the east coast who stayed up for a 22-inning game that started at 7 Pacific, 10 Eastern. That would be likely to end on the late side of 4 AM. Let us indeed hope that never occurs.

Anyway, interesting stuff, thanks.

Jayson Werth Triple Slash Watch: .224/.327/.392
Morspinosa HR Contest Watch: Michael 15, Danny 15
(Figures accurate through 28 June 2011)

by hscer on Jun 29, 2011 5:01 PM EDT up reply actions  

Thing that struck me the most was the 89 batters faced

The majority of pitchers nowadays would be getting close to done after 89 pitches.

Rob

-- In baseball we trust.

by RobBobS on Jun 29, 2011 5:27 PM EDT up reply actions  

you got me looking for more

that’s only the third most batters faced by a single pitcher in a game!
I think I’ve heard of this game before, but I’m not sure
to say anything more would be superfluous, so here’s the box:

http://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/BSN/BSN192005010.shtml

Jayson Werth Triple Slash Watch: .224/.327/.392
Morspinosa HR Contest Watch: Michael 15, Danny 15
(Figures accurate through 28 June 2011)

by hscer on Jun 29, 2011 10:17 PM EDT up reply actions  

Leon Cadore

shares the MLB record for innings pitched in a major league game. He and Joe Oeschger of the Reds each started and pitched 26 innings in a game eventually called for darkness.
thanks to Wikipedia for refreshing the memory details.

Brain: "Pinky, are you pondering what i'm pondering?"
Pinky: "Yes, but isn't a cucumber that small called a gherkin?"

by jbg2772 on Jun 29, 2011 4:19 PM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation's blog about the Washington Nationals. Federalbaseball.com Trying To Make Every Fan A Nationals' Fan.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Cat_coons_small
***Pick6!!!>>>'''PLAY NOW'''<<<Pick6!!!***
Bugs-bunny-baseball_small
New GuessEm Rankings (5/24)

Recent FanPosts

45859-188-008f_small
Why don't more players -- and teams -- do vision training?
Marion2_small
Odd Baseball Question
Joker460_1__small
Philly-Tears Milkshake Brings This Boy Back to The Yahd!
Small
No excuses... too many men left on base
Small
Speed Camera on I-395 in DC coming from VA
Small
Harper HR Poll
Photo-1_small
A few takes, and some queries, from a neophyte
Small
The Gathering Storm

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

GAMETHREAD SPONSOR

Masn_medium

Yahoo_full_count

Ministry of Peace

Rizzo__kasten_and_chigliak_small Patrick Reddington

Ministry of Truth: Records Department (Editor)

Ws1_small Winston Smith

Ministry of Plenty

Teddy_clip_small Doghouse

Shadedlogo_small Dave at District Sports Page

Youppi_040618_mon_a_small bluelineswinger

Small d_c_guy

Adam_o_small jeff550

Imag0320_small SaratogaCountySports