clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Looking back on our preseason predictions for the Washington Nationals

New, 15 comments

So, I think it’s safe to say none of us saw just how great this Washington Nationals season would go, but how did we fare with some of our other preseason predictions...

Washington Nationals Victory Parade Photo by Chaz Niell/Getty Images

It still doesn’t quite feel like it’s only been 16 days since the Washington Nationals won the World Series.

The confetti has settled, the trophy has been lifted, Calma and Baby Shark have been played numerous times, so it’s finally time to reflect on the great season that has just concluded.

This includes looking back on some of the predictions that we made before a pitch was thrown.

On Opening Day, as has become customary among baseball writers these days, we released our preseason predictions. You can find the original post here from March 28th if you want to make sure that we didn’t change any of them below.

Even though a couple of the participants have now left Federal Baseball, let’s remind ourselves of who took part in our preseason predictions before we get underway...

The Participants

  • Patrick Reddington - Converted to part man, part machine after his postseason coverage
  • Will Kubzansky - Recently departed expert wire-tapper
  • Matt Weyrich - Also recently departed newspaper holder-upper guy
  • Blake Finney - Wondering if he scared everyone else off

Who will lead the team in home runs? How many?

  • Patrick - Juan Soto, 30
  • Will - Yan Gomes, 31
  • Matt - Juan Soto, 33
  • Blake - Juan Soto, 37

Answer: Juan Soto and Anthony Rendon, 34

Winner: Matt

Not a great start for Will, who went incredibly bold thinking Gomes was going to be a huge success. At least the other three of us guessed one of the joint-winners. Matt only missed by one, so we’ll give him the “win” on this question.

Who will lead the team in SBs? How many?

  • Patrick - Trea Turner, 50
  • Will - Trea Turner, 53
  • Matt - Trea Turner, 50
  • Blake - Trea Turner, 52

Answer: Trea Turner, 35

Winner: Matt and Patrick

On a 162-game-pace, Turner would’ve stolen 47 bases and made us look a little better by getting close, but unfortunately, he missed 39 games between the start of April and mid-May leaving us all way off. Matt and Patrick get the win by default on this question.

How many saves will Sean Doolittle record?

  • Patrick - 30
  • Will - 29
  • Matt - 39
  • Blake - 40

Answer: 29 saves

Winner: Will

It was a weird season for Sean Doolittle who was his 2018-dominant-self in the early going while the rest of the bullpen was in tatters. That overuse likely led to some struggles and an IL stint toward the end of the year, which brought his saves number down. Will got it on the nose!

Which non-Scherzer pitcher will lead the team in wins? How many?

  • Patrick - Patrick Corbin, 15
  • Will - Stephen Strasburg, 11
  • Matt - Stephen Strasburg, 16
  • Blake - Patrick Corbin, 15

Answer: Stephen Strasburg, 18

Winner: Matt

Well, Scherzer was tied for third with Aníbal Sánchez at 11, despite the best ERA in the rotation at 2.92. I think that’s now known as “doing a Jacob deGrom.” Alas, Stephen Strasburg chalked up a remarkable 18 wins this year, so Matt takes this round.

When will Carter Kieboom make his MLB debut? If at all?

  • Patrick - September
  • Will - Probably no debut — a September cup of coffee, at most.
  • Matt - June 24th
  • Blake - September 4th - 2 days after AAA season finishes

Answer: April 26th

Winner: Matt

Though the Nationals were probably hoping that Carter Kieboom would’ve remained in the minors for most of the season, the wave of injuries they had in the early-going forced their hand. Matt was the only one who thought he’d be more than a September call-up.

Will Anthony Rendon sign an extension? If so, when and how much?

  • Patrick - Rendon signs in May and gets a six-year, $180 million deal
  • Will - I don’t think it’ll get done
  • Matt - No, he becomes a free agent
  • Blake - They lock him up on May 9th to a six-year, $170 million deal with a team option.

Answer: No extension

Winner: Will and Matt

Coming into the season, it looked like there was momentum on a potential Anthony Rendon extension, with a meeting occurring to discuss the subject in mid-April. But now, the third baseman will test the market and see what’s out there for him. Matt and Will win this one.

Name the Nationals’ 2019 All-Stars

  • Patrick - Max Scherzer, Yan Gomes; Juan Soto
  • Will - Juan Soto, Anthony Rendon, Max Scherzer
  • Matt - Max Scherzer, Anthony Rendon, Trea Turner, Juan Soto
  • Blake - Max Scherzer, Juan Soto, Sean Doolittle, Trea Turner

Answer: Max Scherzer and Anthony Rendon

Winner: Will

Just two years removed from having five All-Stars, the Nats only had two representatives this year in Scherzer and Rendon, though neither took part in the game. Will was closest with only Juan Soto incorrectly picked, though the youngster was a notable snub from the game.

Will any Nationals win any end of season awards? If so, who and what?

  • Patrick - Victor Robles RoY
  • Will - Nope. Victor Robles will come in second for RoY, though.
  • Matt - Brian Dozier Comeback Player of the Year
  • Blake - Max Scherzer - Cy Young, Juan Soto - Silver Slugger, Victor Robles - RoY

Answer: Anthony Rendon - Silver Slugger

Winner: Will

The Nats were close on a few awards with Scherzer and Rendon finalists for the Cy Young and MVP respectively. In the end, the only award was Silver Slugger for Rendon. I’m sure they’ll be able to console themselves with the Commissioner's Trophy. Oh, and Will wins.

How many wins will the Nationals have?

  • Patrick - 92
  • Will - 92
  • Matt - 93
  • Blake - 90

Answer: 93 wins

Winner: Matt

As Mike Rizzo says every offseason, his goal is to try and build a team that will win 90 games. This year, they were able to exceed that in the regular season with 93, even though that was only enough for a Wild Card spot. Matt almost looks smart here as he was spot on!

What will the final NL East standings be? (Wildcard marked with a *)

  • Patrick - 1) Nationals 2) Phillies 3) Mets 4) Braves 5) Marlins
  • Will - 1) Nationals 2) Phillies* 3) Braves 4) Mets 5) Marlins
  • Matt - 1) Nationals 2) Phillies* 3) Braves 4) Mets 5) Marlins
  • Blake - 1) Phillies 2) Nationals* 3) Braves 4) Mets 5) Marlins

Answer: 1) Braves 2) Nationals* 3) Mets 4) Phillies 5) Marlins

Winner: Blake

In what looked to be a close-fought race coming into the year, the Braves ran away with the division, the Nationals were a comfortable second, and the Mets and Phillies were on the periphery. I decided I win this on the tiebreaker of having the Nats correct. I need points somehow.

How will the Nationals’ season end?

  • Patrick - NLCS Loss
  • Will - NLDS loss. Things do not change. They never will.
  • Matt - NLCS Loss
  • Blake - NLCS Loss to the Brewers

Answer: Apparently, they won the World Series?

Winner: Everyone except Will

I think everyone knows how the Nationals’ season ended this year and we all missed on the eventual result. The Nats even managed to finally defeat Will’s pessimism. Woohoo!

One bold prediction not covered by the above questions...

  • Patrick - Stephen Strasburg will make 30 starts for the first time since 2014...
  • Will - Patrick Corbin won’t be worth the money. He’ll put up a mid-to-high 3s ERA and will struggle to pitch deep into games.
  • Matt - Juan Soto finishes higher in MVP voting than Bryce Harper
  • Blake - Nationals lead MLB in Catcher WAR (bWAR or fWAR, take your pick)

Winner: Patrick and Matt

There’s a reason they Patrick the “big” bucks as he absolutely nailed his bold prediction with Strasburg recording 33 starts for just the second time in his career. Matt also got his right as Soto popped up on a few MVP ballots while Harper didn’t. Nul points for Will and I.


All of the points have been counted and not ratified. Your 2019 Federal Baseball staff predictions winner is, Matt Weyrich! Matt scored 8 points, with Will coming in second scoring 4, Patrick collects bronze with 3 points, and, well, your boy only scored 2. Whoops.

Also, Jerome Armstrong deserves a shoutout as he (maybe or maybe not entirely seriously) predicted the Nats to win it all in the comments!

We’ll be back again with some predictions ahead of the 2020 season when the Nationals will aim to defend their World Series crown. We can’t wait to be 100% right again.